Top 10 QBs of all time?
KnowETAll
Original post · 7 Jan 2025
Alright, let’s settle this debate once and for all (or maybe stir it up more): Who are your top 10 quarterbacks of all time? I’m talking college or NFL, doesn’t matter – just greatness all around. Everyone’s got their favorites, and I want to hear yours.
For me, Cam Newton’s gotta be on the list. Back in his Auburn days, the man was a one-man wrecking crew. I’ll never forget the 2010 SEC Championship against South Carolina – Cam was unstoppable! I had a cheeky little bet on Auburn covering the spread (I think it was -5.5), and thanks to Newton’s monster performance, I walked away with a nice $500 win. Talk about a QB making you believe in miracles, huh?
So, who are your GOAT QBs? And for extra points, throw in your greatest college football players of all time too – non-QBs included. Some of those guys outshine the pros at the college level.
Looking forward to seeing your lists! Let’s keep it fun, people – no fights over Brady vs. Montana, okay?
For me, Cam Newton’s gotta be on the list. Back in his Auburn days, the man was a one-man wrecking crew. I’ll never forget the 2010 SEC Championship against South Carolina – Cam was unstoppable! I had a cheeky little bet on Auburn covering the spread (I think it was -5.5), and thanks to Newton’s monster performance, I walked away with a nice $500 win. Talk about a QB making you believe in miracles, huh?
So, who are your GOAT QBs? And for extra points, throw in your greatest college football players of all time too – non-QBs included. Some of those guys outshine the pros at the college level.
Looking forward to seeing your lists! Let’s keep it fun, people – no fights over Brady vs. Montana, okay?
6 replies
Percy7 Jan 2025
Tom Brady tops any logical list; his Super Bowl record speaks volumes. For pure talent? Aaron Rodgers. And in the college realm, Archie Griffin is untouchable—two Heismans, after all
A
AnnaBellaDella6 Feb 2025
I don’t gaf about Heismans or MVPs - those awards are all political. Manning has way more MVPs than Brady, do we really think he’s the better QB?
Only thing that matters is trophies. That’s why its Brady then everybody else…except for Patrick f’n Mahomes. Dude is +110 to get his 4th Super Bowl MVP, putting him 1 behind Brady…and he’s got a whole lotta football left.
Only thing that matters is trophies. That’s why its Brady then everybody else…except for Patrick f’n Mahomes. Dude is +110 to get his 4th Super Bowl MVP, putting him 1 behind Brady…and he’s got a whole lotta football left.
T
TheHerbivore6 Feb 2025
Brady’s the GOAT, no argument there. But I gotta give love to Peyton—dude was a field general. Also, prime Cam Newton was a freak of nature, especially in college.
If we’re talking bets, Mahomes at +110 for another Super Bowl MVP is tempting, but I’d check this one for bonuses and updated odds—sometimes they drop some solid boosts for big games.
If we’re talking bets, Mahomes at +110 for another Super Bowl MVP is tempting, but I’d check this one for bonuses and updated odds—sometimes they drop some solid boosts for big games.
nyguy12 Feb 2025
Man, I’ll never forget betting on Mahomes in that 2020 Super Bowl. Down double digits? Didn’t matter. I live bet him to win MVP at +300 mid-game and cashed in HUGE when he pulled that comeback magic. 
You just don’t bet against that dude. Brady is the GOAT for rings, but Mahomes is the closest thing to a cheat code I’ve ever seen.
You just don’t bet against that dude. Brady is the GOAT for rings, but Mahomes is the closest thing to a cheat code I’ve ever seen.
ScanTheMan12 Feb 2025
Brooo I had a buddy who cashed out too early when the Chiefs were down... dude still wakes up sweating over it.Man, I’ll never forget betting on Mahomes in that 2020 Super Bowl. Down double digits? Didn’t matter. I live bet him to win MVP at +300 mid-game and cashed in HUGE when he pulled that comeback magic.
Never count out Mahomes!
RiskyTrailTaker12 Feb 2025
Brady’s resume is undeniable, but peak Manning was something else. 2013 Broncos? 55 TDs, absolute destruction. 
I had him throwing 3+ TDs in a game prop for weeks straight and it never failed. Only time he let me down was that Super Bowl vs Seattle... still hurts.
I had him throwing 3+ TDs in a game prop for weeks straight and it never failed. Only time he let me down was that Super Bowl vs Seattle... still hurts.Join the conversation
Members reply, share payout experiences and flag problems. It’s free.